|
Post by starlord on Jun 3, 2008 20:52:25 GMT -5
Please let us know what you think!
|
|
|
Post by HoM on Jun 4, 2008 5:36:34 GMT -5
Brilliant! A great issue, one of Roy's bests, highlighting everything fantastic about his run so far. Supergirl was just wonderful, and even though I was expecting a cover from Craig (what was going on there?), that cover was beautiful.
I do have to say, I really like what Craig and Ramon did with Supergirl's costume (maybe we could see the full preliminary sketches Craig did?) and it's much better than the horrendous design by Turner (or Churchill?) over in the DCU.
Loved the interaction between Lois and Lombard, Martha and Kara, Kara and Kal, Martha and Klee-- Keelex (I smiled at that)... Everything was just spot on perfect. Congratulations! One more month, I think, and it's been a year! A year of fantastic, true to the concept, Superman stories!
|
|
|
Post by mouseman on Jun 7, 2008 23:42:36 GMT -5
I don't know much about the origin of Supergirl in the comics, other than what I've been told. But this was a very heartfelt way of introducing her into the DC2. I really enjoyed this issue a lot.
|
|
|
Post by arcalian on Jun 10, 2008 18:36:04 GMT -5
Methinks the Congolmerate is in for a severe beatdown!!!!!
|
|
|
Post by David on Jun 14, 2008 22:34:35 GMT -5
Simply fantastic issue. I continue to really enjoy Roy's defintive run on this book--- this is honestly going down as one of my favorite takes on the character! There is something just so sincere and heroic and likable about Roy's Man of Steel that it makes me want to write fan fiction about this fan fiction!
I just always seem to walk away from this title feeling good!
This was a terrific done-in-one story, that quite nicely sets-up Kara/Supergirl. She's not the Silver Age character, and she's not the recent incarnation in the DCU, she's something different, and I'm interested in this new origin. Her final scene with Clark and Martha was classic.
Awesome cover, too! Perfect image for this issue! Looking forward to seeing more of Supergirl in Action... ;D!
|
|
|
Post by goldk on Jun 22, 2008 8:20:59 GMT -5
Thanks for reading and commenting everyone. Sorry about the cover snafu Charlie and Ramon and Craig. I'm sure we'll use the redesign once Kara and Martha get through with it. I was thinking something in gingham Mouseman This was actually in no way similiar to the way I had originally intended to introduce Supergirl, it just kinda happened that way. Arcalian The conglomerate is more than meets the eye! Nope not a transformer. Superman and Supergirl have sure poked a nest of hornets though. I'm glad you walk away from this feeling good Dave, I try to always give Superman a hopefull and a postive outlook. Thanks again for reading and commenting!
|
|
a2uton
Junior Member
Posts: 63
|
Post by a2uton on Jul 31, 2008 10:52:37 GMT -5
Just what weas the cargo? It wouldn't happen to be a bottle c ity full of Kandorians, would it?
|
|
|
Post by Romans Empire on Mar 27, 2009 2:58:19 GMT -5
This was a solid one and done issue and was perfect after the recent three parter. I was honestly shocked by what happened to Kara's adopted world. Kind of a shame that it had to happen that way.
Makes me curious now about the whole Planetary Conglomerate and what will happen now that Superman and Supergirl are on their radar.
I throughly enjoyed seeing a throwback character like Steve Lombard give Lois a hard time. The more he’s around the better.
Plus another Fero connection huh? I can’t wait for the big crossover event!
Having Martha take Kara in was a sweet touch. And the Kleenex comment was cute as well.
Loved the cover as well as seeing Kara have a bigger role in the book. Can’t wait to see what happens next.
5 stars.
|
|
|
Post by oblique on Jan 3, 2018 11:18:40 GMT -5
I'm going back through Action Comics and very much enjoyed this interesting new origin story for Supergirl, starting in issue 24 up to issue 31. Supergirl (Kara Zor-El) is one of my favourite characters in DC Comics and I was excited to see her in DC2, although I am going backwards from Charlie's amazing run on Superwoman.
Roy's understanding of Superman is amazing and his portrayal of the character is spot on. Supergirl is a great complement to the Man of Steel. I love seeing Martha and 'the Farm' as part of this origin story, and how intertwined Kara is with Kal's life on Earth. Keelex making an appearance as a phone is awesome - I sense a little Transformers, but in a good way! I also like removing Luthor from the board for a bit to let the Super-Family stretch their wings.
Great run!
|
|
|
Post by HoM on Jan 7, 2018 7:40:39 GMT -5
I'm going back through Action Comics and very much enjoyed this interesting new origin story for Supergirl, starting in issue 24 up to issue 31. Supergirl (Kara Zor-El) is one of my favourite characters in DC Comics and I was excited to see her in DC2, although I am going backwards from Charlie's amazing run on Superwoman. Roy blew my mind when he did the bait and switch with Kara's rocket. "What Ifs" are a big part of fan fiction, but it's rare you get something so intrinsically different be integrated into the legend as we did with Kara Zor-El landing on the jungle world first, before being introduced to Earth. In my head canon, which I'll eventually get out on paper, Kara is traumatised by what happened after the destruction of Krypton, so much so that even when she arrives back into a "civilised" society like the one on Earth, she still has trouble adapting. By the time Superman leaves Earth, thus triggering the 10YL timeline, she's fully socialised so that you don't see any of the feral behaviour that she might have had to lean into on the jungle planet, but if we caught up with her in the current continuity, she might not be 100% the Kara you expect yet. Being marooned on a deserted planet full of weird and wonderful creatures could really do a number on you. She's like the Green Arrow of the Superfamily, though there's no archery involved, just the marooned aspect! Roy's understanding of Superman is amazing and his portrayal of the character is spot on. Supergirl is a great complement to the Man of Steel. I love seeing Martha and 'the Farm' as part of this origin story, and how intertwined Kara is with Kal's life on Earth. Keelex making an appearance as a phone is awesome - I sense a little Transformers, but in a good way! I also like removing Luthor from the board for a bit to let the Super-Family stretch their wings. Great run! I loved Roy's run on Action Comics, there was such reverence to the character, but also a willingness to take risks that I was really happy he accepted my challenge of taking up writing duties. Before this, we worked together on a back-up that ran early on in my run called " Escape To Krypton", a murder mystery based in a new location we created in Metropolis called Krypton Square, that housed the super-powered oddities and weirdos that cropped up in the 90s Superman family of titles. I was really pleased with that-- if I remember rightly, I gave him a kernel of a plot and he ran with it. The title itself, a play on the old " Return to Krypton" stories that used to pop up every decade or so in the Superman books, was the starting point. Here's something cool, let's run with it! I think that the site never really had a handle on how to use Lex Luthor broadly. We started off with him being a kind of Michael Rosenbaum Smallville Luthor by way of Superman: The Animated Series Luthor, because we relied so heavily on Smallville's mythos for our version of the Superman legend. He was a very nasty piece of work, but had that public front, then when our second year anniversary event came around, " Justice League Vs America", he was outed as a supervillain, and never really returned from that position. We got a lot of evil Lex running around in his powersuit causing problems, which I think is great, but because we didn't have that broad understanding of him, we were stuck with him being a supervillain and not able to do the kind of insidious stories he's most famous for in the public eye, like the great Cadmus-arc in Justice League Unlimited, or the 2000s President Lex. If you read Green Lantern Corps, by the time #57-59 rolls around you'll know that he's back in the good graces of Metropolis... but how? That's going to be revealed in the next few months, in a story that's going to surprise everyone when it comes around. So in the current continuity, Lex has his business back, he's had all his criminal charges dropped, and Metropolis doesn't give him a second though. That's going to be the plan for the long term, but we do know that by the time 10YL rolls around, he's in prison, so it's not like he gets away with it forever!
|
|
|
Post by oblique on Jan 7, 2018 15:15:31 GMT -5
Interesting! I'd love to see evil-but-manipulative-and-subtle Lex return in Green Lantern! Can't wait.
Maybe someone will pick up the story of Supergirl in an ongoing one day, because there's great potential there.
|
|
|
Post by HoM on Jan 7, 2018 15:27:36 GMT -5
Interesting! I'd love to see evil-but-manipulative-and-subtle Lex return in Green Lantern! Can't wait. I was really happy with the Lex-centric arc over in Green Lantern Corps, and I'm writing him again in this year's Action Comics Annual. That, and an appearance in an arc that launches with Justice League #75... we'll be seeing a lot of the "untouchable" version of Lex moving forward in this year's books. You should be worried! Maybe someone will pick up the story of Supergirl in an ongoing one day, because there's great potential there. I keep wanting to use Superwoman in Justice League, but the timeline doesn't intersect in the correct way! That said, I had intended to use Red Robin-- Tim Drake from the future-- in my last run on the title, but I stalled and took a break from the site for a while. That was going to be part of the defunct " The Omega Point" era of the site, that truncated time which had the Big Seven going in one direction, and a ragtag team running in the ongoing. I've mentioned the concept of the Decade title before, which would feature stories from the decade leap toward Omega Crisis and after, but it could also feature stories from the current timeframe... or perhaps a miniseries of her own! I know I had plans for the intervening years that weren't covered in Superwoman, but what I want to do is feature her and Lena's budding relationship instead! So many threads... not enough time... or titles!
|
|
|
Post by oblique on Jan 7, 2018 20:58:56 GMT -5
That's true! I'm buzzing with ideas, but there's definitely not enough time to do them all (I'm trying to stay focused, ha!) Anthology-style issues may be the best way to doodle on some characters I've always liked, one day anyways!
|
|