Post by HoM on Jun 19, 2019 13:23:33 GMT -5
Charlie said:
S.E, eh? Looks like there seems to be some special relations going on behind the scenes in the Marvel2... Wonder what that could mean! I must say though, that it's been a long time that we've thought of Charles Xavier as a master of his field, and not just the mutant trainer of the X-Men. I remember the 90s, when he was shot by Cab-- Stryfe, excuse me, and Wolfsbane went to go see him in the hospital and everyone was like "I don't think we should be seen here, they'll put two and two together and come up mutant...", and I miss that kind of secrecy.
Damn you, Grant Morrison!
Anyway, I loved this ("Professor X-Something", you're very good with those sly moments of humour, Brian) issue. It continues to build on the amazingly strong foundations of your first issue, and I have to say that what you're doing with Magneto is very fun and different. The Marvel2, I think, is better than other Marvel fan fiction sites, not only because we have talents such as Brian, Craig, Roy, Borize, Don, Pat, Kevin, Aaron, Jay, Viktor, Trevor, James, and Ramon lurking about creating wonderful stories, is that we're not afraid to deviate from the norm. We could have copied what they're doing now in the MarvelU proper, but where's the fun in that?
We have to take concepts that work, tweak them, improve them, and set them loose. If we don't adapt to the audiences, to the wantings of the community, what's the point?
... Oh, and lastly... Erik Xavier? You're a genius, Brian. That whole little play by Magneto? Genius.
I'll be back.
With popcorn, preferably. This is how X-Men should be written, and I'm glad that you're on this book.
Have a raise.
Don said:
Take care
Don
Swgb24 said:
It seems to me that every issue of Brian's just gets better and better. Each story is woven with such ease and excitement that it makes it impossible for an audience not to love it. Brian, you have really outdone yourself this time. Five stars.
P.S: I cannot begin to tell you how wide my grin was when I read the: "Oh my stars and garters" line.
Therougerogue said:
Definately liked this one better then the first. Magneto's plan is potentially brilliant, interesting to see where it goes from here.
Only real complant was that it was kind of confusing to follow early on. Between the real and 'fake' Erik in two different places and then Quicksilver and Wanda appearing for the fight.
nice issue over all though. Solid four stars and looking forward to next month.
James.
Aaron said:
There are so many moments I enjoyed. The use of Mastermind, who was once very prominent in the early 616 as well, was executed brilliantly. I love the Scarlet Witch and enjoyed her strong, prominent and powerful role here. Colossus is already beginning to have doubts, and could that lead to a change of teams when he learns more about the Brotherhood and the X-Men? I found a civil conversation between Xavier and Magneto to be absorbing. And I totally love what you're doing with Magneto, both in his characterization and his ambitious plot to take over. Magneto as President? Pretty ballsy.
The X-Men themselves are again presented just the way I like them, and I enjoy all the little gems of humor you throw in, something I consider to be a hallmark of your writing.
It's also interesting to see a world that is just becoming aware of mutants and doesn't know what to make of them yet. Do we trust them or fear them? A fascinating avenue to explore here, I would think. Again, kudos on another terrific work.
l1701e said:
Hmmm, I gotta give it to Mags here for his little plan on painting the X-Men as the bad guys. He shouldn't given that idea a shot in the comics.
Magneto: *singing and dancing* I am so smart! I am so smart!
Scarlet Witch: I can't believe half my DNA came from him. No wonder I went bonkers in the comics.
And I liked seeing Quickie and Witchie make their Marvel2 debuts. And Magneto's plan was a neat one, too.
Mastermind: Where'd he come up with the idea?
Toad: He read Donald Trump's new book.
Can't wait for more!
Brian said:
I guess it is the first two pager. I didn't plan it that way, though.
Nothing like opening a couple of doors, just in case a certain EIC wants to run with it.
I couldn't have said it better myself, Sir!
I'll second that one as well! ;D
Thank you. I'm trying to stay true to what Stan The Man wanted to do, but update it a bit. I hope it's working.
Thank you.
The popcorn will be $4.50. Would you like to super size that for .50 cents more?
Thank you for reading and responding, my friend!
Brian said:
Take care
DonWell, to be honest Don, this was more your idea than mine. Your discussions with Kevin about this team, and my snarky comment that you actually liked, made this story possible. I'm glad your enjoying it!
Brian said:
I'm very glad that the pacing seems to work, I worry a lot about that. I tend to find what I write to be slow and boring, but hey, if it works for everyone... cool!
It does take a bit of juggling and sometimes I will probably focus on some characters a bit more than others.
I'm really glad Cyke is coming out well for you. I think you hit the nail on the head!
Well, like I said, this wasn't completely my idea at all, but a combination of a discussion that was had. As for Maggie telling Charles his plan... well... he is a bit on the arrogant side.
Thank you very much. That's very kind of you.
You know, I really wanted to save the comment for an even bigger moment, but I just couldn't. It's my favorite phrase of any Marvel character.
Brian said:
Definately liked this one better then the first. Magneto's plan is potentially brilliant, interesting to see where it goes from here.
Only real complant was that it was kind of confusing to follow early on. Between the real and 'fake' Erik in two different places and then Quicksilver and Wanda appearing for the fight.
nice issue over all though. Solid four stars and looking forward to next month.
James.
Thank you sir, and after this was up and I read it again, I was thinking the same thing as you. The entire Erik Xavier stuff was a bit confusing, but now that Magneto is going to take over the role that Mastermind created the illusion of, it should get easier... I hope.
Thank you for taking the time to read and respond.
Brian said:
Thank you! I blush.
I'm glad you liked him, here, because Mastermind was always one of my favorite Brotherhood members, and there's much more to him than meets the eye.
Both the Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver are major players in this story, and Colossus as well. I will give you a bit of a spoiler by saying that by the time this part of this "epic" is over, at least two member of the Brotherhood, may be heading towards Xaviers Institute.
One of the things I loved about Charles and Erik was the concept that they were friends who's beliefs were what drove them apart. Yet, the respect for each other never waivered.
Thank you and glad you're liking the team. I've always kind of thought that the best drama should have a bit of humor in it... and verse visa.
And THAT is what I'm really loving at this point. Everything about mutants is new in the Marvel2, which means it could go anywhere. ;D
Thank you for taking the time to read and respond.
Brian said:
Hmmm, I gotta give it to Mags here for his little plan on painting the X-Men as the bad guys. He shouldn't given that idea a shot in the comics.
Magneto: *singing and dancing* I am so smart! I am so smart!
Scarlet Witch: I can't believe half my DNA came from him. No wonder I went bonkers in the comics.
And I liked seeing Quickie and Witchie make their Marvel2 debuts. And Magneto's plan was a neat one, too.
Mastermind: Where'd he come up with the idea?
Toad: He read Donald Trump's new book.
Can't wait for more!
HAHAHAHAHAHA!!!
I love your thoughts and comments. They always make me laugh! Thanks for responding! Keep coming back! ;D
Universeman said:
I don't know where that came from.
Anyway, Magneto is a brilliant planner and manipulator, his group is growing in numbers and his kids are the same, but it's always nice to see them. The X-Men are beginning to come together as a super-team and get kicked to the curb by the Bro-hood. Of course, this leaves Iceman on his own. What will happen there?
Great stuff. Keep it up.
-UM
Brian said:
I don't know where that came from.Neither do I, but I liked it! ;D I'm also glad you enjoyed Mastermind. He's probably my favorite of the original Brotherhood
The Brotherhood does seem to be out numbering the X-Men at the moment, huh?
Thank you good Sir! And thank you for reading as well! I hope the best is yet to come.
Pat said:
Anyway, I was quite happy with the read. The plot is rock solid and the story flow was excellent. Magneto's plan is a good one... and I can only guess where this is going.
This feels like a much grander scale then I first expected it to be. I'm looking forward to seeing what Brian has in mind for our band of (not so) merry mutants.
I also liked the feel of the mood in the book..l slightly humorish, but with a underlying feel that anything can happen at any moment. Almost gives you a strange feel of parinoia.
Well done cover also. Good job all around!
Brian said:
Wow, that's humbling. Thank you.
He's going straight to hell if he doesn't change his ways. Oops, sorry, I was channeling my grandmother for a moment.
Oh this is going to get big. VERY big!
Hmmm... Paranoia? Interesting choice of word.
Thank you for taking the time to read and to respond. It always means a lot to get feedback, good or otherwise. It means people have taken the time to read your work... and nothing can be more appreciated than that.
l1701e said:
I love your thoughts and comments. They always make me laugh! Thanks for responding! Keep coming back! ;DNo problem!
Mouseman68 said:
I'm a little concerned about Colossus being on the side of The Brotherhood, and I do have one question. The cover (great cover, I might add) also shows Nightcrawler in the Brotherhood, but he was not mentioned in the story. Why?
Also, can you give us any hints on who is hiding behind the glass that can actually keep Charles from using his powers? Please tell me it's Emma? Is it Emma?
Brian said:
Actually, I took out the scene with Kurt in it, but have no fear, he's in this next issue.
You want a hint... okay... Cassandra Nova. Or not...
Brian said:
But I promise that X-Men #3 will be out by Saturday! I swear this too you who want to read it. And I will never be late with this title again!
Again, my apologies.
Yikes! First impression of this is that it's going to be epic! Is this the Marvel2s first two-pager? Wow. Couldn't have happened to a greater book!
S.E, eh? Looks like there seems to be some special relations going on behind the scenes in the Marvel2... Wonder what that could mean! I must say though, that it's been a long time that we've thought of Charles Xavier as a master of his field, and not just the mutant trainer of the X-Men. I remember the 90s, when he was shot by Cab-- Stryfe, excuse me, and Wolfsbane went to go see him in the hospital and everyone was like "I don't think we should be seen here, they'll put two and two together and come up mutant...", and I miss that kind of secrecy.
Damn you, Grant Morrison!
Anyway, I loved this ("Professor X-Something", you're very good with those sly moments of humour, Brian) issue. It continues to build on the amazingly strong foundations of your first issue, and I have to say that what you're doing with Magneto is very fun and different. The Marvel2, I think, is better than other Marvel fan fiction sites, not only because we have talents such as Brian, Craig, Roy, Borize, Don, Pat, Kevin, Aaron, Jay, Viktor, Trevor, James, and Ramon lurking about creating wonderful stories, is that we're not afraid to deviate from the norm. We could have copied what they're doing now in the MarvelU proper, but where's the fun in that?
We have to take concepts that work, tweak them, improve them, and set them loose. If we don't adapt to the audiences, to the wantings of the community, what's the point?
... Oh, and lastly... Erik Xavier? You're a genius, Brian. That whole little play by Magneto? Genius.
I'll be back.
With popcorn, preferably. This is how X-Men should be written, and I'm glad that you're on this book.
Have a raise.
Don said:
Very good issue, Brian. Great pacing, good mystery and action, and the plot by Magneto is wonderfully convoluted and grandiose. I love the twist on his plotting, using Xavier's own dreams as a weapon against him. Brilliant! this it the maggie I know and love. Well-done.
Take care
Don
Swgb24 said:
Mar 16, 2008 18:53:14 GMT -5 @swgb24 said:
Wowza, and Brian knocks another one out of the park, actually, I think you just knocked this one out of the state. Yet again, I am in utter awe and amazement at your talent to create a fascinating story. Above all I must emphasize your complete understanding and grasp of pacing. This is a long book, like, really long, yet, amazingly enough, I never felt bored with. Ever. There was not one second of this book where I was not enjoying myself. The story and all the characters are superbly written, and I cannot imagine how hard it must be to write so many characters at a time and give them all enough screen-time, yet Brian does this without a hitch. I'm loving the use of the original X-Men, and particularly the use of Cyclops. I think you've given Scott the perfect attitude, he is kind of a prick at times, but you can really see why he is. This is a man who takes his job very seriously, something which I think a lot of newer interpretations of the character need to take into account. Magneto's plan, as noted by Charlie, is absolutely genius, I'm not sure how I feel about him telling Charles it, but, thats a minor detail. I cannot wait to see where this is going!It seems to me that every issue of Brian's just gets better and better. Each story is woven with such ease and excitement that it makes it impossible for an audience not to love it. Brian, you have really outdone yourself this time. Five stars.
P.S: I cannot begin to tell you how wide my grin was when I read the: "Oh my stars and garters" line.
Therougerogue said:
Just a short review this time.
Definately liked this one better then the first. Magneto's plan is potentially brilliant, interesting to see where it goes from here.
Only real complant was that it was kind of confusing to follow early on. Between the real and 'fake' Erik in two different places and then Quicksilver and Wanda appearing for the fight.
nice issue over all though. Solid four stars and looking forward to next month.
James.
Aaron said:
Mar 17, 2008 12:14:56 GMT -5 @aaron said:
Brilliant second issue, Brian. I agree with Viktor that, despite the story's length, I wasn't bored for an instant and it felt like the issue just breezed by.There are so many moments I enjoyed. The use of Mastermind, who was once very prominent in the early 616 as well, was executed brilliantly. I love the Scarlet Witch and enjoyed her strong, prominent and powerful role here. Colossus is already beginning to have doubts, and could that lead to a change of teams when he learns more about the Brotherhood and the X-Men? I found a civil conversation between Xavier and Magneto to be absorbing. And I totally love what you're doing with Magneto, both in his characterization and his ambitious plot to take over. Magneto as President? Pretty ballsy.
The X-Men themselves are again presented just the way I like them, and I enjoy all the little gems of humor you throw in, something I consider to be a hallmark of your writing.
It's also interesting to see a world that is just becoming aware of mutants and doesn't know what to make of them yet. Do we trust them or fear them? A fascinating avenue to explore here, I would think. Again, kudos on another terrific work.
l1701e said:
Hey, all!
Hmmm, I gotta give it to Mags here for his little plan on painting the X-Men as the bad guys. He shouldn't given that idea a shot in the comics.
Magneto: *singing and dancing* I am so smart! I am so smart!
Scarlet Witch: I can't believe half my DNA came from him. No wonder I went bonkers in the comics.
And I liked seeing Quickie and Witchie make their Marvel2 debuts. And Magneto's plan was a neat one, too.
Mastermind: Where'd he come up with the idea?
Toad: He read Donald Trump's new book.
Can't wait for more!
Brian said:
Yikes! First impression of this is that it's going to be epic! Is this the Marvel2s first two-pager? Wow. Couldn't have happened to a greater book!
S.E, eh? Looks like there seems to be some special relations going on behind the scenes in the Marvel2... Wonder what that could mean!
I must say though, that it's been a long time that we've thought of Charles Xavier as a master of his field, and not just the mutant trainer of the X-Men. I remember the 90s, when he was shot by Cab-- Stryfe, excuse me, and Wolfsbane went to go see him in the hospital and everyone was like "I don't think we should be seen here, they'll put two and two together and come up mutant...", and I miss that kind of secrecy.
Damn you, Grant Morrison!
Anyway, I loved this ("Professor X-Something", you're very good with those sly moments of humour, Brian) issue. It continues to build on the amazingly strong foundations of your first issue, and I have to say that what you're doing with Magneto is very fun and different. The Marvel2, I think, is better than other Marvel fan fiction sites, not only because we have talents such as Brian, Craig, Roy, Borize, Don, Pat, Kevin, Aaron, Jay, Viktor, Trevor, James, and Ramon lurking about creating wonderful stories, is that we're not afraid to deviate from the norm. We could have copied what they're doing now in the MarvelU proper, but where's the fun in that?
... Oh, and lastly... Erik Xavier? You're a genius, Brian. That whole little play by Magneto? Genius.
I'll be back.
With popcorn, preferably. This is how X-Men should be written, and I'm glad that you're on this book.
Have a raise.
With popcorn, preferably. This is how X-Men should be written, and I'm glad that you're on this book.
Have a raise.
Thank you for reading and responding, my friend!
Brian said:
Very good issue, Brian. Great pacing, good mystery and action, and the plot by Magneto is wonderfully convoluted and grandiose. I love the twist on his plotting, using Xavier's own dreams as a weapon against him. Brilliant! this it the maggie I know and love. Well-done.
Take care
Don
Brian said:
Mar 16, 2008 18:53:14 GMT -5 @swgb24 said:
Wowza, and Brian knocks another one out of the park, actually, I think you just knocked this one out of the state. Yet again, I am in utter awe and amazement at your talent to create a fascinating story. Above all I must emphasize your complete understanding and grasp of pacing.This is a long book, like, really long, yet, amazingly enough, I never felt bored with. Ever. There was not one second of this book where I was not enjoying myself. The story and all the characters are superbly written, and I cannot imagine how hard it must be to write so many characters at a time and give them all enough screen-time, yet Brian does this without a hitch.
I'm loving the use of the original X-Men, and particularly the use of Cyclops. I think you've given Scott the perfect attitude, he is kind of a prick at times, but you can really see why he is. This is a man who takes his job very seriously, something which I think a lot of newer interpretations of the character need to take into account.
Magneto's plan, as noted by Charlie, is absolutely genius, I'm not sure how I feel about him telling Charles it, but, thats a minor detail. I cannot wait to see where this is going!
It seems to me that every issue of Brian's just gets better and better. Each story is woven with such ease and excitement that it makes it impossible for an audience not to love it. Brian, you have really outdone yourself this time. Five stars.
P.S: I cannot begin to tell you how wide my grin was when I read the: "Oh my stars and garters" line.
Brian said:
Just a short review this time.
Definately liked this one better then the first. Magneto's plan is potentially brilliant, interesting to see where it goes from here.
Only real complant was that it was kind of confusing to follow early on. Between the real and 'fake' Erik in two different places and then Quicksilver and Wanda appearing for the fight.
nice issue over all though. Solid four stars and looking forward to next month.
James.
Thank you for taking the time to read and respond.
Brian said:
Mar 17, 2008 12:14:56 GMT -5 @aaron said:
Brilliant second issue, Brian. I agree with Viktor that, despite the story's length, I wasn't bored for an instant and it felt like the issue just breezed by.There are so many moments I enjoyed. The use of Mastermind, who was once very prominent in the early 616 as well, was executed brilliantly.
I love the Scarlet Witch and enjoyed her strong, prominent and powerful role here. Colossus is already beginning to have doubts, and could that lead to a change of teams when he learns more about the Brotherhood and the X-Men?
I found a civil conversation between Xavier and Magneto to be absorbing. And I totally love what you're doing with Magneto, both in his characterization and his ambitious plot to take over. Magneto as President? Pretty ballsy.
The X-Men themselves are again presented just the way I like them, and I enjoy all the little gems of humor you throw in, something I consider to be a hallmark of your writing.
It's also interesting to see a world that is just becoming aware of mutants and doesn't know what to make of them yet. Do we trust them or fear them? A fascinating avenue to explore here, I would think. Again, kudos on another terrific work.
Thank you for taking the time to read and respond.
Brian said:
Hey, all!
Hmmm, I gotta give it to Mags here for his little plan on painting the X-Men as the bad guys. He shouldn't given that idea a shot in the comics.
Magneto: *singing and dancing* I am so smart! I am so smart!
Scarlet Witch: I can't believe half my DNA came from him. No wonder I went bonkers in the comics.
And I liked seeing Quickie and Witchie make their Marvel2 debuts. And Magneto's plan was a neat one, too.
Mastermind: Where'd he come up with the idea?
Toad: He read Donald Trump's new book.
Can't wait for more!
I love your thoughts and comments. They always make me laugh! Thanks for responding! Keep coming back! ;D
Universeman said:
Mar 18, 2008 1:54:11 GMT -5 @universeman said:
Lots of mutant stuff happening here. Mastermind lives up to his name. I can actually imagine him saying "Step right up and find the Professor! Only five dollars for three tries! Find the Professor and win this wonderful stuffed bear!"I don't know where that came from.
Anyway, Magneto is a brilliant planner and manipulator, his group is growing in numbers and his kids are the same, but it's always nice to see them. The X-Men are beginning to come together as a super-team and get kicked to the curb by the Bro-hood. Of course, this leaves Iceman on his own. What will happen there?
Great stuff. Keep it up.
-UM
Brian said:
Mar 18, 2008 1:54:11 GMT -5 @universeman said:
Lots of mutant stuff happening here. Mastermind lives up to his name. I can actually imagine him saying "Step right up and find the Professor! Only five dollars for three tries! Find the Professor and win this wonderful stuffed bear!"I don't know where that came from.
Anyway, Magneto is a brilliant planner and manipulator, his group is growing in numbers and his kids are the same, but it's always nice to see them. The X-Men are beginning to come together as a super-team and get kicked to the curb by the Bro-hood. Of course, this leaves Iceman on his own. What will happen there?
Great stuff. Keep it up.
-UM
-UM
Pat said:
Mar 19, 2008 13:16:12 GMT -5 @patnestor said:
Haven't been the biggest X-Men fan the last few years.. but hey... It's Brian.Anyway, I was quite happy with the read. The plot is rock solid and the story flow was excellent. Magneto's plan is a good one... and I can only guess where this is going.
This feels like a much grander scale then I first expected it to be. I'm looking forward to seeing what Brian has in mind for our band of (not so) merry mutants.
I also liked the feel of the mood in the book..l slightly humorish, but with a underlying feel that anything can happen at any moment. Almost gives you a strange feel of parinoia.
Well done cover also. Good job all around!
Brian said:
Mar 19, 2008 13:16:12 GMT -5 @patnestor said:
Haven't been the biggest X-Men fan the last few years.. but hey... It's Brian.Anyway, I was quite happy with the read. The plot is rock solid and the story flow was excellent. Magneto's plan is a good one... and I can only guess where this is going.
This feels like a much grander scale then I first expected it to be. I'm looking forward to seeing what Brian has in mind for our band of (not so) merry mutants.
I also liked the feel of the mood in the book..l slightly humorish, but with a underlying feel that anything can happen at any moment. Almost gives you a strange feel of parinoia.
Well done cover also. Good job all around!
Well done cover also. Good job all around!
Thank you for taking the time to read and to respond. It always means a lot to get feedback, good or otherwise. It means people have taken the time to read your work... and nothing can be more appreciated than that.
l1701e said:
HAHAHAHAHAHA!!!
I love your thoughts and comments. They always make me laugh! Thanks for responding! Keep coming back! ;D
Mouseman68 said:
Apr 6, 2008 3:26:07 GMT -5 @mouseman68 said:
my favorite Marvel team book, and so far this is just as fun to read as the team was back in its "silver age". I'm a little concerned about Colossus being on the side of The Brotherhood, and I do have one question. The cover (great cover, I might add) also shows Nightcrawler in the Brotherhood, but he was not mentioned in the story. Why?
Also, can you give us any hints on who is hiding behind the glass that can actually keep Charles from using his powers? Please tell me it's Emma? Is it Emma?
Brian said:
Apr 6, 2008 3:26:07 GMT -5 @mouseman68 said:
I'm a little concerned about Colossus being on the side of The Brotherhood, and I do have one question. The cover (great cover, I might add) also shows Nightcrawler in the Brotherhood, but he was not mentioned in the story. Why?Also, can you give us any hints on who is hiding behind the glass that can actually keep Charles from using his powers? Please tell me it's Emma? Is it Emma?
Brian said:
Folks, I owe you all an apology. For the first time that I can remember in the nearly 4 years of writing, I'm late.
But I promise that X-Men #3 will be out by Saturday! I swear this too you who want to read it. And I will never be late with this title again!
Again, my apologies.